Stroke associated with cardiac surgery is the most important postoperative non-cardiac major complication. Carotid stenosis is associated with a higher risk of perioperative and postoperative stroke. Studies have shown that approximately 3% of patients with CABG and concomitant asymptomatic and severe carotid stenosis have a stroke. In addition, this rate increased to 5% in those with bilateral carotid stenosis
10. Therefore, carotid revascularization before CABG may reduce the incidence of stroke. Although researchers have advocated the potential benefits of varying treatment strategies due to combined or staged surgical therapy, there is no consensus in national or international clinical treatment guidelines.
Causes of stroke in open-heart surgery; atherosclerotic debris embolization from the ascending aorta, embolization of ventricular mural thrombi, air, fat, or platelet aggregates, thromboembolic events of the carotid artery, inadequate preoperative antiplatelet therapy and hemodynamic instability, and cerebral hypoperfusion 8,11-14 have been reported. Previous studies have shown that CAS is not one of the leading causes of perioperative stroke, except for severe bilateral carotid bifurcation stenosis 7. In addition, previous stroke and TIA have been found to be the main predictors of perioperative stroke 8.
In the present study, we attempted to identify high-risk patients' preoperative predictors for CAD and to estimate the incidence of CAD using carotid artery Doppler USG examinations before elective coronary revascularization. Severe CAD was defined as ≥80% stenosis of one of the carotid arteries. We also evaluated combined treatment (CEA+CABG) and postoperative neurological complications. Our examination changed the treatment trend in the minority of patients and there was no significant correlation between these changes and reduced perioperative stroke risk.
Previous studies also recommended preoperative color Doppler USG in patients with a history of TIA or stroke within the past six months to reduce stroke risk in CABG patients 8. Consistent with our study and other retrospective studies, it is reasonable to identify high-risk patients and to perform non-invasive imaging; otherwise, the imaging of all patients who are scheduled for CABG would be time-consuming and expensive 15. In brief, preoperative carotid artery color Doppler USG is recommended for only those aged >70 years, having multi-vessel disease, PAD, and carotid murmur among those without a history of stroke or TIA within the past six months 8. In addition, it is not indicated in emergency CABG in patients without a history of stroke or TIA.
In the present study, 384 of 480 patients had mild CAS (≤50%). Moderate CAS (50 to 79%) and severe CAS (≥80%) or complete occlusion were detected in 60 and 36 patients, respectively. Faggoli et al. 12 found the rate of severe stenosis (≥75%) to be 8.7% in 539 asymptomatic patients using preoperative Doppler USG. In another study, Berens et al. 16 found an internal carotid artery (ICA) stenosis of ≥80% in 5.9% of the study population (n=1.087) aged above 65 years scheduled for cardiac surgery. These study findings are consistent with our results, indicating that doppler USG is a reliable tool for the evaluation of preoperative CAS.
In our study, prior CEA, PAD, presence of preoperative neurological symptoms, and advanced age were the main predictors of severe CAD. Of note, the mean age was older in patients with severe CAD than those without (66±6.5 years vs. 62.5±10 years, respectively). Similarly, Faggioli et al. 12 reported that the incidence of ≥75% CAS was 11.3% and 3.8% in patients aged above 60 years and under 60 years, respectively. In the current study, 25% of the patients with severe CAS had prior CEA in the contralateral carotid artery. The rate of patients with severe CAS without prior CEA was 2%. Consistent with our findings, Schwartz et al. 17 and Salasidis et al. 18 reported that prior CEA was a significant risk factor for severe CAS. In addition, PAD was observed in 58.3% and 9.4% of the patients with and without severe CAS, respectively (P=0.0013). Likewise, Sutton et al. 19 suggested that PAD was the major determinant for CAD in the elderly with isolated systolic hypertension. In their study, Ahn et al. 20 also reported the incidence of severe CAS (≥80%) as 5% in asymptomatic PAD patients.
In the present study, the rate of previous neurological disorders was 25% and 6% in the patients with and without severe CAS, respectively (P=0.048). Consistent with our findings, Schwartz et al. 17 found the advanced age, prior CEA, preoperative cerebrovascular symptoms, and the presence of cervical murmur and PAD to be significant risk factors for severe CAD. In our study, sex, smoking, presence of diabetes, hypertension, hyperlipidemia, angina, congestive heart failure, previous myocardial infarction were not found to be significant risk factors for severe CAD. Similarly, Schwartz et al. 17 found no significant correlation between CAD and systemic and cardiac risk factors such as hypertension, diabetes, myocardial infarction, left main coronary disease, and smoking.
Furthermore, the overall neurological in-hospital mortality and morbidity was 3.2% in 459 CABG patients in our study. Six of 15 neurological complications were observed in patients with severe CAD (≥80%), while the other six patients with less CAS (<80%) had neurological complications. Three patients died from cerebrovascular accidents. In their study, Salasidis et al. 18 found that the postoperative incidence of neurological complications was 18.2% in 22 CABG patients with severe CAS (≥80%) and 1.7% in 354 patients with less CAS (<80%). In a study including 38 patients, Yilmazkaya et al. 21 showed that none of the patients treated with combined surgery had a stroke in the postoperative period and the mortality rate due to low cardiac output was 2.6%. In another study including 128 asymptomatic cardiac surgery patients, Faggioli et al. 12 demonstrated that the stroke incidence was 14% in patients with >75% CAS. In their study including 582 patients, in another study including 300 CABG patients, Ulger et al. 22 showed that postoperative stroke was responsible for one in four deaths (1.3%) and that postoperative stroke was correlated with >50% CAS and a previous history of stroke. On the other hand, we detected 40% CVA after isolated CABG in cases with more than 80% stenosis. In cases with stenosis less than 80%, we observed CVA rate of 1.3% after CABG. The rate of exitus due to CVA was 0.6%. In our study, the stroke incidence was 1.3% in patients without severe CAS, consistent with previous studies. However, the stroke incidence was higher in our patients with severe CAS due to the small sample size with severe CAS, although not statistically significant.
More importantly, patients with neurological disorders were older than those without any neurological events in our study. In addition, PAD, CAD, and preoperative neurological symptoms were more frequent in these patients. Similarly, Gardner et al. 23 found a significant correlation between postoperative stroke and advanced age, cerebrovascular accidents, ascending aortic atherosclerosis, and prolonged CPB. In another study, Tuman et al. 24 found a stroke incidence of 0.9% and 8.9% in patients aged under 65 years and above 75 years, respectively. Faggioli et al. 12 also reported a stroke incidence of 11.3% and 3.8% in patients above 60 years and under 60 years, respectively following CABG. In our study, the stroke incidence was unable to be evaluated according to age groups. However, patients with neurological disorders were older in our study.
In a previous study including 1,1779 patients, Ricotta et al. 25 found a significant correlation between postoperative stroke and >50% CAS, redo cardiac surgery, valve surgery, and a previous history of neurological disorders. In the aforementioned study, there was also a significant correlation between postoperative mortality and >50% CAS, redo cardiac surgery, PAD, prolonged pump time, and hyperlipidemia and the authors reported a stroke rate of 1.6% and a mortality rate of 3.1%. In our study, 40% of the patients with ≥80% CAS had a cerebrovascular accident after isolated CABG, while this rate was 1.3% in patients with less than 80% stenosis. The cerebrovascular accident-related mortality rate was 0.6%.
In the current study, 21 of 36 patients with severe CAS underwent combined treatment (CEA+CABG). Nine of these patients were symptomatic, while twelve patients were asymptomatic. None of the patients treated with combined surgery had postoperative neurological complications. Bitao et al. 26 in their study with 245 coronary bypass patients, they reported a stroke rate of 9.38% and a 6-month mortality rate of 3.13% in 32 patients they applied combined surgery. Berens et al. 16 reported the incidence of stroke as 6.5% after combined surgery and 7.4% in elderly patients. Yılmazkaya et al. 21 In the study in which they examined 38 patients who underwent combined surgery, stroke was not observed in any patient in the postoperative period and they reported that the mortality due to low flow rate was 2.6%. Some authors have also suggested that combined treatment reduces the incidence of late stroke and perioperative stroke, as it is performed under the same anesthesiology session 15,27. According to the results of our study; Combined CEA / CABG is the most ideal treatment method to be preferred in the presence of coronary artery disease and severe carotid disease.
Nonetheless, the present study has certain limitations. First, it has a retrospective design with relatively small sample size. Second, it has a single-center design that precludes the generalization of the findings. Third, we were unable to identify the etiology of stroke whether it was caused by thrombosis, embolism, or hypoperfusion in each individual patient. Further large-scale, prospective studies are needed to confirm these findings.
In conclusion, our study results show that advanced age, presence of PAD, previous cerebrovascular accidents, and prior CEA are the main risk factors for CAD. Patients having at least one of these risk factors should undergo a detailed carotid artery color Doppler USG examination before CABG, which is a reliable and non-invasive diagnostic tool. In patients with CAD accompanied by coronary artery disease, staged surgery is recommended (CEA followed by CABG), in case of a stable cardiac condition. However, CABG is associated with a higher risk for neurological complications in asymptomatic unstable angina patients with carotid artery murmurs (<50%) or moderate CAS (50 to 75%) with a previous history of stroke. In patients with severe bilateral CAD or symptomatic CAD accompanied by unstable angina, left main coronary artery disease, or diffuse multi-vessel disease, combined surgery can yield the most favorable outcomes. In patients with greater stenosis, CEA should be applied to the carotid artery supplying the dominant hemisphere first and, then, CABG should be undertaken. The contralateral carotid artery should be treated with CEA a couple of days later. Finally, the presence of CAD is one of the major determinants of mortality and morbidity following CABG in patients with atherosclerotic coronary artery disease. Therefore, these patients should be carefully evaluated before CABG to minimize postoperative complications.